Different results between equivalent Triangular Channel and Gutter worksheets


Product(s):Bentley FlowMaster
Version(s):08.11.01.03
Area:Calculations

Problem

Computed results (such as Discharge) are different between a Triangular Channel and Gutter worksheet, with equivalent configuration.

Solution

Although both worksheets solve the Manning equation, a modification is applied with gutters, due to how the top width of flow is so much greater than the depth. See equations 6.2 and 5.25 in the Help to compare:

Equation 5.25, Manning Equation:


 

Equation 6.2, Mannings Equation for triangular gutters:

See Also

Small difference in gutter worksheet result between US and SI units