Error Code 37 - STRESSES AND DISTORTIONS : Stress(es) exceed(s) allowable


Question:

When analyzing a model in AutoPIPE Vessel the following warning number was reported. 

37        STRESSES AND DISTORTIONS : Stress(es) exceed(s) allowable (Operation (Normal Wind) (1 D + 0.6 W) (Corroded inertias) (New Weight))

Why and how to avoid it?

Answer: 

After generating a complete output report, find under the Vessel combination loading section, "Stress and Distortion"> Warning  for the appropriate load case mentioned in the error message (ex. (Operation (Normal Wind) (1 D + 0.6 W) (Corroded inertias) (New Weight)).  Then scroll up through the report to find the troubled area(s).

 

Example #1: 

 

 

As seen in the example above, the minimum required thickness is 0.13 in but the model setting is currently 0.1 in. 

 

Solution:

After modifying the component so "tmin" is less than "t", the error message will no longer be displayed. 

 


Example #2: 

 

37    STRESSES AND DISTORTIONS : Stress(es) exceed(s) allowable (Operation (Seismic(++)) (Corroded inertias) (Corroded Weight))

 

Open the report section to find:

Notice the allowable values are all set to ft = 0.00. 

Why and how to fix it?

recommended trouble shooting and resolution steps:

      1. Open the offending component(s): (example Component 25.06)
      2. Since this is an allowable issue, open and review the Material tab information for the component.
      3.  While reviewing the tabs, found the Design (Int) and Design (Ext) both have missing information for Exceptional Allowable Stress. A value must be entered from the material library or from the user. 
      4. Question: why is the Library value not shown?
      5. Answer: Hint... 
        1. What material is the component made out of? (ex.. Nickle Alloy, ASME II, N08031)
        2. What code is the used for evaluation? (ex.. En 13445: 2021-05)
        3. What materials are supported by the code (ex. En 13445 does not support Nickel Alloy)
      6.  At this point, the design code for this model does not support allowable value equations (ex. En 13445: 2021-05 Table 6-1). There is only 2 possible solutions. 
        1. Manually update the program to use a specific library equation
          1. Open Design Condition tab on the Heat Exchanger Properties dialog
          2. Manually select Safety Factor>User define> press the Edit button 
          3. On the Untabulated Allowable Stresses Computation dialog, select Nickel Alloy
          4. Update the Normal conditions as needed.
          5. Review all the other materials making updates as needed, when all values are acceptable for the project pick OK button.  
          6. Note: be careful to select the correct Chamber No.: during these modifications.
        2. Or, Manually enter a value into the Exceptional Allowable Stress User field.

Conclusion 

A reported stress failure does not necessarily mean that the calculated component stress itself is the underlying problem. When the allowable value is 0.00, first investigate the material and allowable-stress definition. Verify that the selected design code supports the component's material. If it does not, provide the required allowable-stress calculation or manually enter the appropriate Exceptional Allowable Stress value.

The actual allowable-stress value should be established from the applicable project/code requirements rather than inferred solely from the error message.

See Also

AutoPIPE Vessel

Error messages