Error Code 27 - Tubesheet Loading condition, longitudinal membrane stress


Applies To  
Product(s): AutoPIPE Vessel
Version(s): ALL
Area: Errors
Date Logged
& Current Version
March 2018
40.06.00.07

Problem:

What to do to avoid the error in the floating head design

27 Tubesheet loading conditions, longitudinal membrane stress in the tubes exceeded

Solution:

After running Strength Calculations search the output report for all occurrences of "Longitudinal membrane stress" or "not maintained".  

There is failure due to tube axial membrane stress, the tubes do not meet the allowable conditions:

The report image shown above indicates the following to the user:

      1. The stress does not meet the conditions of the code, thus "Not Maintained" is printed in red.
      2. These series of equations can be confusing, but careful review and text coloring should help the user's understanding when is failing and why.  
      3. Conditions to meet for Outer tubes (see chart below):
        1. Tensile loaded tubes (+ve values): |st,0| shall be £ ft,j
        2. Compress loaded tubes (-ve values): |st,0| shall be £ ft,bk 
      4. Conditions to meet for Inner Tubes (see chart below):
        1. Tensile loaded tubes (+ve values): |st,i| shall be £ ft,j
        2. Compress loaded tubes (-ve values): |st,i| shall be £ ft,bk
      5. Note: values for st,0 and st,i are to be evaluated as absolute

Avoidance:

There are many possible solutions to this issue, consider using one or more of the following:

#1: Review the Code calculations and adjust the variables to affect a desired change:

Essentially, review the code calculations for those equations that are failing (ex. longitudinal membrane stress in the outer tubes) and adjust one or more of the variable values in the model such that the stress is no longer negatively affecting the evaluation and failing the code condition (ex.  compressed tube |st,0| shall be £ ft,bk ).

#2: Increase Tube thickness:

Increasing Bundle (A) tube thickness (B) may help remove all of the tube membrane stress errors but that might not be a solution from process/thermal design perspective as tube becomes too thick:

#3: Increase the number of Baffles

Another solution could be to reduce baffle spacing (example - increase the number of baffles from 7 to 10 reduces the spacing). Remember after changing the baffle spacing on this dialog, be sure to update the Bundle component Longitudinal View to account for the change. 

.

This process may require multiple iterations. Upon decreasing the baffles spacing, examine the identical failing location documented in the report to determine whether the this action has produced the intended outcome.

Note: may need to remove the Distance Tubesheet / 1st value to avoid undesirable affects. Notice all baffles are bunched up around the 1st tubesheet instead of evenly distributed.

After updating the bundle component correctly, increasing the baffles to 12, the error code 27 no longer appears in the software or reports:

Overall it really depends on what approach the designer wants to adopt.

See Also

AutoPIPE Vessel

Error messages