10. How are a support's axial force due to xxx load case calculated in AutoPIPE's reports?


Applies To  
Product(s): AutoPIPE
Version(s): ALL;
Area: Results
Original Author: Bentley Technical Support Group
Date Logged
& Current Version
April. 2017
11.00.00.22

Problem:

How are supports axial force due to xxx load case calculated in AutoPIPE's reports?

Example: 

With the give piping arrangement :

Why are axial support forces for all operating load cases not all Fnormal x Friction Coeff (ex. 1000 lbs x 1 = 1000)?

Note:

a. Pipe was assumed to have 0 density

b. Specific Gravity = 0.00

c. V-stop support Friction coefficient = 1.0

d. Rigid anchor at Node point A00

e. 3 Thermal loads have been defined with different thermal expansion values (T1- low, T2 - med, T3 - high)

f. Only weight in system is added Weight = 1000 lbs at node point A02.  

Solution:

Basically, pipes with a load case applied horizontal to the support will experience a resistant ‘static friction’ up to the maximum allowed friction, which is the product of the friction factor, f, and the normal force, N. Until the maximum value has been reached, the pipe does not move. After the critical friction force is met (), slippage occurs and ‘kinetic friction’ dominates. The pipe begins to move in the direction of the load. See the following plot created to help visualize, where the blue line is the support force and the red line is the support displacement.

 

Again, note from the plot above, the pipe displacement remain 0.00 (red line) until the maximum resistance force has been reached (blue line) causing the pipe to move. The pipe may continue moving but the force required cannot be larger than the maximum resistance force calculated.  

Detailed Examination of Example:

First look at displacement in the axial direction for the support node point(s):

Notice that the displacement due to operating conditions, ex. GT1 and GT2, are essentially 0.00 inches; while the displacement for GT3 was >0.00. Now look at the forces acting on the support by the respective operating conditions. Understand in order for the pipe to move, a pulling / pushing force = Fnormal x Friction Coeff must be applied. Otherwise the node point will not move. 

In the example above,

Fnormal = 1000 lbs

Friction Coef = 1.00

Fpush = Fnormal x Friction Coeff 

Fpush = 1000 lbs x 1.00

Fpush = 1000 lbs. 

Again, so long as a Fpush force was >1000 lbs, node point will be displaced, conversely any value of Fpush <1000, node point will not move. AutoPIPE's output report indicates a maximum force or portion of the maximum force required to move the piping node point.

Please see the following AutoPIPE help section for more details on this topic: 

Help > Contents> Contents Tab> Reference Information> Analysis Considerations > Static Analysis > Nonlinear Analysis > Support Friction Properties

Results are affected by:

Please see the following AutoPIPE help section for more details on this topic:

Help > Contents> Contents Tab> Reference Information> Analysis Considerations > Static Analysis > Nonlinear Analysis > Force Tolerance and Friction Tolerance

Adjust the non-linear settings as required to get closer to the nominal friction force calculated by hand.  

Scenario #2:

How can the axial support force be larger that the maximum resistance force and still not cause any pipe movement?

example: Given

- max downward load on the support= -27221 N

- coeff of friction = 0.3

- Maximum resistance force = 27221 N x 0.3 = 8166.3 N

- Analysis type = Non-linear Analysis

How can the maximum load on the support be 15409 N for T1 load-case and with no pipe movement (i.e. displacement = 0.00) ?

Answer:

The most important aspect to remember, this is a Non-Linear Analysis type. As such the only results that should be considered are Operating Condition combinations, ex. GrT1P1, Sus+E1, ect. Do Not consider the individual load-case (i.e. T1, P1, E1, Gr, etc..) unless trying to understand how the results for an Operating Condition combination are being calculated.

The following explanation may help clarify the results of AutoPIPE. Again, for non-linear load sequences the result of an individual load case may not make sense if load sequence was ignored.

 

1st:

Gravity is the first load case in the load sequence. Downward force at that time is 27,222 N downwards. This when multiplied by the friction coefficient gives 8167 N which is the maximum resistance the friction can give. The direction of this force on the support is +X global.

2nd:

The thermal force acts in the opposite direction (-X global). It first cancels out the existing gravity load, and then continue to act in the -X direction developing friction force on the support in the -X direction. The results for GT1{1} combination would make more sense in this case showing that now the lateral load on the support is 7,301 (still under the downward force * friction coefficient limit), but is now acting in the opposite direction.

3rd:

Pressure load case was applied acting in the +X direction canceling out a portion of the thermal load force (P1 = 91 N)

4th, 

The operating condition combination, GT1P1{1},  gives the final state of support forces which was calculated to be 7,210 N in the -X global direction. Again, since the Maximum Resistance Force had not been reached there was no pipe movement. 

Scenario #3:

Problem Description:

Why does AutoPIPE report different axial force values in the following output reports?

The model uses the following conditions:

Explanation:

The values are different because the two reports represent different physical quantities.

Two longitudinal pressure-related forces must be considered:

    1. Pressure end force, caused by internal pressure acting over the internal cross-sectional area of the pipe.
    2. Pressure extension restraint force, required at the anchor to prevent the pipe from extending longitudinally.

The Anchor report and Forces & Moments report displays the force required to restrain the longitudinal pressure extension.

The Code Stresses report uses the net longitudinal pressure force for code-stress post-processing.

The following calculations are based on the values provided in attached excel sheet.

 

1. Input Data

The example uses the following pipe and pressure properties:

Property Symbol Value
Pipe outside diameter OD 1016 mm
Pipe wall thickness t 12 mm
Pipe inside diameter ID 992 mm
Pipe length L 100,000 mm
Cold modulus of elasticity Ec 207,000 N/mm²
Poisson’s ratio ν 0.27
Design internal pressure p 1.6 N/mm²
 

2. Calculate the Internal Pipe Area

3. Calculate the Pipe Metal Cross-Sectional Area



This area is used when calculating axial strain, extension, restraint force, and longitudinal stress in the pipe wall.

4. Calculate the Pressure End Force




This represents the total longitudinal force generated by internal pressure acting on the pipe’s internal cross-sectional area.
This value can be verified in AutoPIPE by creating a User Combination that includes only the applicable longitudinal pressure load.
Define the "Long" at Stress Level and set the Category to Sustained. When the Code Stress results for this combination are reviewed, the reported axial force corresponds to the end-cap force generated by internal pressure.
As shown in screenshot below:

5. Calculate the Free Longitudinal Pressure Extension

This is the longitudinal extension associated with the pressure end force before accounting for the circumferential expansion and Poisson’s effect.

6. Calculate the Longitudinal Contraction Due to Poisson’s Effect


This value represents the longitudinal contraction associated with Poisson’s effect from the pressure-induced circumferential strain.

7. Calculate the Net Pressure Extension


Therefore, if the pipe were free to move, the pressure loading would produce a net longitudinal extension of approximately 7.26 mm.

8. Calculate the Force Required to Prevent Pressure Extension


This is the axial force displayed in the Anchor report and Forces & Moments report for the pressure load case. It represents the restraint force required at the anchor to prevent the pipe from undergoing longitudinal pressure extension.
The small difference between the manual value and the AutoPIPE result can occur because the manual calculation uses rounded input and displayed values, while AutoPIPE performs the analysis using the model’s internal precision and detailed section properties.

9. Calculate the Net Axial Force Used in Code Stresses


This value is displayed in the Code Stresses report as the axial force.

Therefore:

The manual calculation confirms that the reported values are consistent, allowing for rounding and the internal precision used by AutoPIPE.

10. Calculate the Stress Due to Restrained Pressure Extension

This is the axial stress produced by restraining the pipe’s pressure-induced longitudinal extension.

11. Calculate the Longitudinal Pressure Stress


This represents the longitudinal pressure stress before subtracting the stress associated with the restrained pressure extension.

12. Calculate the Net Pressure Stress


This confirms that AutoPIPE uses the net longitudinal pressure effect for code-stress post-processing.

13. Summary of Results

Calculated quantity Manual result AutoPIPE result/report
Pressure end force 1,236,611 N Approximately 1,236,611 N in pressure-related code output
Pressure extension 15.7833 mm Intermediate calculation
Poisson-related contraction 8.5230 mm Intermediate calculation
Net pressure extension 7.2603 mm Intermediate calculation
Force required to prevent extension 568,841 N Approximately 568,790 N in Anchor and Forces & Moments report
Net axial force 667,770 N Approximately 667,821 N in Code Stresses
Stress due to restrained extension 15.0289 N/mm² Intermediate stress component
Longitudinal pressure stress 32.6714 N/mm² Pressure end-force stress
Net pressure stress 17.6426 N/mm² Approximately 17.64 N/mm² in Code Stresses
 

The manual-calculation results and the corresponding AutoPIPE output values are provided in attached excel sheet.

Conclusion:

The axial force in Anchor and Forces & Moments should not be expected to match the axial force in Code Stresses because the reports represent different pressure-related quantities.

The Anchor Forces & Moments value of approximately 568,790 N represents the force required at the anchor to prevent the pipe from extending under internal pressure.

The Code Stresses value of approximately 667,821 N represents the net longitudinal pressure force used during code-stress post-processing.

Minor differences between the manual calculations and the reported AutoPIPE values are expected due to rounded displayed inputs and the higher numerical precision used internally by AutoPIPE.

See Also

"Support" sub report

Analysis Sub-reports FAQ

Bentley AutoPIPE